Sudoku books and apps label difficulty as “beginner”, “intermediate”, and “advanced”, or with a number of stars. What decides that? Here is how the NumberPlace app sets ★1 to ★5 as an example.

Difficulty Is Decided by the Techniques You Need

The app’s stars are set by the hardest technique needed to solve the puzzle. The techniques are divided into four tiers, easiest first.

TierTechniquesCount
1Singles3
2Locked candidates and pairs4
3Triples, X-Wing, and more5
4XY-Wing and more3

Tier 1 is Full House, Hidden Single, and Naked Single. Tier 2 is Pointing, Claiming, Naked Pair, and Hidden Pair. Tier 3 is Naked Triple, Hidden Triple, X-Wing, Naked Quad, and Hidden Quad. Tier 4 is XY-Wing, XYZ-Wing, and Swordfish (All the Sudoku Techniques).

Tier 1 techniques place a digit directly with “only this square can hold it” or “only this digit fits” (How to Solve Sudoku). From tier 2 up, the techniques write candidates and cross them out (Advanced Sudoku, How to Solve Hard Sudoku).

The Stars for 9×9

StarsTechniques neededNumber of digits
★1 EasyUp to Hidden Single36 to 40
★2 NormalNaked Single30 to 35
★3 HardTier 224 to 31
★4 ExpertTier 3 or higher, once22 to 31
★5 MasterTier 3 or higher, twice or more22 to 31
  • ★1 can be solved just by looking for “where in this box (row, column) can this digit go?”
  • ★2 also needs the move of focusing on a square and settling “only this digit fits”.
  • ★3 requires you to write candidates and cross them out with locked candidates and pairs.
  • ★4 and ★5 both need techniques from tier 3 or higher. Using an advanced technique just once is ★4, and using one two or more times is ★5.

In puzzles made in the usual way, ones that need tier 3 or higher are very rare, so ★4 and ★5 are split by “how many times” rather than “which tier” (The Hardest Sudoku in the World).

The Stars for the 6×6 Mini

The 6×6 board is small, and most puzzles can be solved with singles alone. So ★1 to ★4 are split by the number of starting digits.

StarsTechniques neededNumber of digits
★1 Many cluesSingles20 to 22
★2 More cluesSingles16 to 18
★3 Fewer cluesSingles13 to 15
★4 Fewest cluesSingles10 to 12
★5 TechniquesTier 2 or higher8 to 13

Only ★5 is made of puzzles that can’t be solved with singles, and many of them need the XY-Wing (How to Solve the 6×6 Mini).

How This Matches Beginner, Intermediate, and Advanced

The “beginner, intermediate, advanced” in books and other apps use different standards depending on who made them. Roughly, you can think of it like this.

  • Beginner: Solvable with singles alone (the app’s ★1 and ★2).
  • Intermediate: Write candidates and use locked candidates and pairs (★3).
  • Advanced: Needs techniques like the X-Wing and XY-Wing (★4 and ★5).

If It Feels Hard

There’s no shame in going down one star. Solving lots of puzzles you can solve is the better way to pick up techniques. The first time you open the app, it’s set to 9×9 ★2. If it feels hard, you can switch to ★1 or the 6×6 Mini, and if it feels too easy, to ★3, from Settings.

When you’re stuck, Hint shows you the next square you can settle and the reason. From the wording of the reason, you can also tell which technique that puzzle needed.