In the news and online, puzzles called “the world’s hardest sudoku” sometimes get attention. They are introduced as specially hard puzzles made by mathematicians and puzzle designers. But there is no official standard for deciding what is “the world’s hardest”. Which puzzle is hardest changes depending on how you measure difficulty.

It Isn’t Decided by the Number of Clues

People tend to think “the fewer digits at the start, the harder”, but that isn’t always so.

In the NumberPlace app’s 9×9, the number of digits placed at the start is as follows.

DifficultyNumber of digits
★1 Easy36 to 40
★2 Normal30 to 35
★3 Hard24 to 31
★4 Expert22 to 31
★5 Master22 to 31

For ★3 to ★5, the ranges overlap. There are ★5 puzzles with 30 digits, and ★3 puzzles with 24. More than the number of digits, where you can get a foothold decides the difficulty.

Difficulty Is Decided by the Techniques You Need

Sudoku difficulty is usually measured by how advanced the techniques are that you need to solve it. The NumberPlace app’s stars are set the same way.

  1. Solvable with singles alone (“only this square can hold it” and “only this digit fits”) → easy
  2. Needs locked candidates or pairs → hard
  3. Needs triples, the X-Wing, the XY-Wing, the Swordfish, and so on → expert and master

How many times you use an advanced technique also affects difficulty. In the app, ★4 is a puzzle that needs an advanced technique once, and ★5 needs one two or more times.

A puzzle called “the world’s hardest” is one where you get stuck even after using all of these techniques, and you can’t solve it without more complex techniques or long chains of assumptions.

How Rare Are Hard Puzzles?

Using the same method as the NumberPlace app (starting from a completed board and erasing digits in point-symmetric pairs), we made 300 9×9 puzzles and checked them. Digits keep being erased as long as the puzzle can still be solved all the way with techniques.

Hardest techniqueNumber of puzzles
Singles only243 (about 81%)
Up to locked candidates and pairs40 (about 13%)
Needs an advanced technique17 (about 6%)

In other words, hard puzzles don’t come out easily when you make them the usual way. The app prepares its ★4 and ★5 puzzles by regenerating many times until one needs an advanced technique (How to Make a Sudoku).

If You Want to Take On Hard Puzzles

  • First, in ★3, get used to using locked candidates and pairs (Advanced Sudoku).
  • Next, in ★4 and ★5, practice looking for the X-Wing and XY-Wing (How to Solve Hard Sudoku).
  • Puzzles called the world’s hardest are for people who have learned all of these techniques and want to take on ideas that go further. There’s no need to be disappointed if you can’t solve them.