In Shisen-Sho, you can sometimes end up with tiles left but not a single pair you can remove. This is called getting “stuck.” This article covers how often that happens and what to do when it does.
What “Stuck” Means
It is a state in which no pair can be removed. In the diagram below, for example, two tiles of each picture remain, but neither pair can be connected by a line.
For two tiles with the same picture facing each other diagonally, both squares that would be the corner of an L-shaped line are blocked by other tiles. The area around them is open, but any way around takes three or more turns.
How Often Do You Get Stuck?
We had a computer play 2,000 boards of 48 tiles dealt the same way as in the Shisen-Sho app.
| How the tiles were removed | Games stuck |
|---|---|
| Pick any pair you can remove | 11 games (0.55%) |
| Remove from the top of the board in order | 39 games (1.95%) |
Either way, even when removing tiles without any thought, most games could be cleared to the end. Every deal in the app has at least one way to remove all the tiles, so getting stuck is rare to begin with. In the 11 games stuck while picking at random, the number of tiles left when stuck was between 4 and 16, with a median of 8. So getting stuck mostly happens near the end.
How the board is made is explained in How the App Makes Solvable Deals.
If You Get Stuck: Shuffle
In the Shisen-Sho app, when no pairs are left to remove, it says “No more matches,” and you can choose Shuffle. Shuffling places the remaining tiles again, within the squares they currently occupy, in a layout you can clear. You can always clear the board after a shuffle.
There is no limit on the number of shuffles, and no penalty.
Trying Another Way with Undo
Instead of shuffling, you can also use Undo to put back the pairs you removed, one at a time. You can look for where you paired the tiles wrongly and remove a different pair.
However, you cannot go back past a shuffle. A shuffle changes the layout, so it would no longer match the earlier removals. If you want to solve it on your own, try going back a few moves before you choose Shuffle.
How to Avoid Getting Stuck
A common way to get stuck is when the last two tiles of a picture are boxed in far apart from each other. Get in the habit of checking where the other two tiles are before you remove a pair. For details, see Shisen-Sho Tips and What to Do When There Are Four Identical Tiles.
