Lines in Shisen-Sho can turn “at most two times.” That “two” gives just the right difficulty. We used a computer to compare what happens if you change the limit on turns.
How We Checked
We made 1,000 boards of 6 columns by 8 rows with 48 tiles (12 kinds × 4) placed at random (we did not use the app’s way of making solvable deals). We changed the turn limit to 0, 1, 2, and 3, and counted these two things.
- The number of pairs you can remove at the start (the average over 1,000 deals)
- The number of deals in which you could clear every tile when you kept picking pairs at random from the ones you could remove
Lines can pass through the one-square border outside the board under every limit.
Results
| Turn limit | Pairs removable at the start | Deals cleared |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 5.4 | 0 |
| 1 | 5.4 | 113 |
| 2 | 9.3 | 927 |
| 3 | 18.1 | 1000 |
0 and 1 Turns: Too Hard
With 0 turns (straight lines only), none of the 1,000 deals could be cleared. A straight line can join only two tiles in the same row or column, and it cannot go around the outside.
With up to 1 turn, only 113 of the 1,000 deals could be cleared. The number of pairs removable at the start is the same as with 0 turns because at the start the board is packed with no gaps, so the corner square of an L shape is never open. At the start, you can remove only adjacent pairs.
3 Turns: Too Easy
With up to 3 turns, all 1,000 deals could be cleared even by picking pairs at random. The number of pairs removable at the start also averages 18, about double that of two turns. Pairs that two turns cannot reach around the outside, such as tiles in opposite corners, become removable, so you can move ahead with hardly any thinking.
The East Wind tiles in opposite corners in the diagram above cannot be removed with up to 2 turns, but with up to 3 turns they connect by going around the outside.
2 Turns: You Can Clear It If You Think
With up to 2 turns, 927 of the 1,000 deals could be cleared even by picking pairs at random. But in the remaining 10% or so, you get stuck. You have about 9 pairs to remove at the start on average, so there is room to choose.
“Even if you pick at random, you can usually get far. But if you do not think about the order, you sometimes get stuck.” Two turns gives just that right difficulty.
The Shisen-Sho app makes its deals so that you can always clear them, so it has somewhat more removable pairs than a randomly placed board (about 14 on average; see How Many Pairs Can You Remove at the Start?). For what to do when you get stuck, see When You Get Stuck: Shuffle.
