Minesweeper is a game of logic, but some people say “it comes down to luck in the end.” The answer is that it depends on how the board is built.

  • With the usual way of placing mines at random, you can reach places that logic cannot settle.
  • On a board built from the start so that it can be solved by logic alone (a no-guess board), you never need to guess. The boards in the Minesweeper app are of this kind.

The 50/50 That Logic Cannot Settle

The diagram below shows a position where only the two squares at the top left remain. The two flags are already settled as mines by the numbers.

??2132111

There is one mine in one of the two ”?” squares. But:

  • The “1” at row 2, column 1 touches both of the two squares.
  • The “3” at row 2, column 2 also touches both of the two squares, plus the two flags.
  • No other number touches these two squares.

Every number sees the two squares in the same way, so whether the left one or the right one is the mine, the numbers you can see are exactly the same. Even using the number of mines on the whole board cannot tell them apart. If you count every possible mine layout, each is exactly 50% (for how to count probabilities, see Minesweeper Probability).

A position like this is a “50/50,” and here you have no choice but to pick by luck instead of logic.

How Often Does It Happen with Random Placement?

On boards the same size as the app’s, we calculated how often a board can be solved to the end by logic alone when the mines are placed at random. The results come from opening the middle of the board first (with no mines on that square or around it) and then proceeding using only the same “three rules of deduction” as the app. We ran 20,000 trials for each.

BoardMinesShare solvable
Level 1 9×78about 84%
Level 2 12×916about 69%
Level 3 15×1027about 40%
Level 4 20×1245about 30%
Level 5 26×1575about 23%

The bigger the board and the higher the share of mines, the more boards get stuck partway. On boards the size of Level 5, more than three in four randomly placed boards could not be solved using the three rules alone.

However, some boards can be solved with deeper deduction than the three rules, such as thinking about three or more numbers at once or counting every layout. The share of boards that truly need luck is smaller than the share that could not be solved in this table.

Why 50/50s Happen

50/50s happen because, when mines are placed, nobody considers “whether it can be solved by logic.” Depending on where the mines are, you can end up with a pair of squares that no number can tell apart. The diagram above is an example in a corner of the board, but the same thing can happen in the middle of a board.

No-Guess Boards: No Luck Needed

There is a way to check, when building a board, whether it can be solved by logic alone. The Minesweeper app builds boards with the following steps.

  1. Place no mines on the first square you tap or around it.
  2. Place mines on the remaining squares and check whether everything can be opened from the first square using only the three rules of deduction.
  3. If it gets stuck partway, move one of the mines causing it to a deeper square that nobody has touched yet, and check again.
  4. If it still cannot be fixed, place the mines again.

The board is built the moment you make your first tap, so whichever square you start from, it can be solved by logic from there. We calculated how many times mines get moved in How No-Guess Boards Are Made. The three rules of deduction are: what you can tell from a single number, what you can tell by combining two numbers, and what you can tell from the mines left on the whole board.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I do when I reach a 50/50?

In ordinary Minesweeper, you have no choice but to pick. But before you pick, if you first open all the squares that logic can settle elsewhere, new numbers may appear and the 50/50 may go away.

Do no-guess boards make the game easy?

You just stop losing by luck, and you still need logic. When we generated 3,000 boards each of Levels 4 and 5 in the same way as the app and counted, more than 90% of them needed a deduction combining two numbers (Combining Two Numbers). A few boards also needed the mines left in the endgame to be settled.

What if I get stuck in the app?

The app’s boards can be solved by logic, so there is a clue somewhere. Press “Hint” and the next square you can work out lights up with a gold ring.