In the app Sort Puzzle, each tube holds 4. Each color has 4 pieces too, so when a color is gathered, the tube is exactly full.
So what happens to solvability if the tube capacity changes? I counted by computer.
How I Checked
- Set the capacity to 3, 4, 5, and 6, and prepare that many pieces of each color.
- Shuffle the colors, fill the tubes that hold colors, and add one or two spare tubes.
- Leave out any deal that has a tube with a run of one color of “capacity minus 1” or more (with the app’s capacity of 4, that is the same as leaving out tubes with a run of 3 or more). With a capacity of 3, though, this rule would not even allow a run of 2 and would be too strict, so I counted those without leaving anything out.
- For 300 deals each, try every move and check whether the deal can be solved.
With One Spare Tube
The share of deals that could be solved came out like this.
| Capacity | 3 colors | 5 colors | 7 colors |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 92.3% | 48.0% | 22.0% |
| 4 | 73.3% | 26.3% | 6.0% |
| 5 | 59.3% | 16.7% | 0.7% |
| 6 | 48.0% | 7.7% | 0.0% |
With the same number of colors, the larger the capacity, the harder it was to solve. With 7 colors and a capacity of 6, not one of the 300 deals could be solved.
With bigger tubes, more colors pile up in a single tube, and you have to move more colors out of the way before you reach the one at the bottom. It seems to be because, with only one spare tube, you quickly run out of places to put the colors you moved.
With Two Spare Tubes
With two spare tubes, the result changes completely. For every combination of capacity 3 to 6 and 3 to 7 colors, all 300 deals I counted could be solved.
★1 through ★4 in the app also have two spare tubes, and in the range I counted, every deal could be solved as dealt (see How Solvable Puzzles Are Made). Only ★5, with one spare tube, has trouble finding deals that can be solved.
Summary
- With one spare tube, the larger the tubes and the more colors there are, the more deals can’t be solved.
- With two spare tubes, changing the tube size or the number of colors made no difference. Every deal in the range I counted could be solved.
- The number of spare tubes matters much more for solvability than the number of colors or the tube size.
For how to think about a puzzle with one spare tube, see How to Solve ★5 (One Spare Tube) and Examples of Unsolvable Deals.
