The app Sort Puzzle shows only puzzles that have been confirmed to be solvable. That means there are also deals that can’t be solved however you move from the start. I checked every one in small puzzles to see which boards can’t be solved.
With 2 Colors and 1 Spare Tube, the Only Unsolvable Deal
Take a puzzle with 4 red and 4 orange packed into 2 tubes, plus one empty tube. If you count deals that differ only by the order of the tubes or by the colors being repainted as the same, there are 23 kinds of deals. Of those, only 1 kind can’t be solved.
Both tubes are, from the bottom, red, orange, orange, red. Here are all the positions you can reach from this puzzle.
- The red from tube 1 into the empty tube 3.
- The red from tube 2 onto the red in tube 3.
- You might think of putting the two oranges from tube 2 into tube 1, but tube 1 has room for only one.
In the last position, the only move you can make is passing orange back and forth between tubes 1 and 2, and going back and forth returns you to the same shape (the two reds in tube 3 can’t move anywhere). Even if you choose a different move from a position along the way, you just return to one of these four positions. The positions you can reach, including the starting puzzle, are only 4, and none of them is sorted.
In both Pour and Stack, the positions you can reach were the same 4.
Why It Can’t Be Solved
In this puzzle, red is at the bottom of both tubes. As covered in Which Color Should You Gather First?, if one color is at the bottom of two tubes, one of the tubes has to be emptied at some point.
To empty a tube, you have to move the two oranges and the red on top of it into other tubes. But the top of both tubes is red, so at first the only thing you can do is put a red into the empty tube. Then the empty tube becomes a red tube, and there is no place left that can take the two oranges together (each tube has room for just one).
With 3 Colors and 1 Spare Tube, About a Quarter Can’t Be Solved
For puzzles with 3 colors, red, orange, and yellow, plus one empty tube, there are 995 kinds of deals (not counting differences in tube order and repainted colors), and 236 kinds could not be solved. Even limiting it to fair deals, with no tube holding a run of three or more of one color, 198 of 736 kinds (about 27%) can’t be solved.
This deal can’t be sorted however you move either. Your first move has to go into the empty tube 4, and whichever of the 3 options you choose, you eventually hit a dead end.
With Two Spare Tubes
With two spare tubes, the story is completely different.
- Every deal with 2 colors and 2 spare tubes, or 3 colors and 2 spare tubes, could be solved.
- Even with 4 colors and 2 spare tubes (the size of ★1), all 111,383 kinds, including unfair deals, could be solved (see How Many Starting Puzzles Are There?).
Just one more spare tube makes the unsolvable deals vanish. This is why most deals can’t be solved in ★5, which has only one spare tube (see How Solvable Puzzles Are Made).
