★5 (Grandmaster) in the app Sort Puzzle is a puzzle with 9 colors and only one spare tube. It has fewer colors than ★4 (10 colors, 2 spare), but it feels much harder. Here is how to think about solving it, based on what I learned by trying every move in ★5.

More Than Half of Puzzles Are Already Lost After the First Move

A ★5 puzzle starts with all 9 tubes full, with 4 each. The only place you can move to is the empty tube 10, so your first move is one of 9: which of the 9 tubes to take the top from and put into tube 10.

I generated 39 ★5 puzzles the same way the app does, and for each first move, I tried every move after it to see whether the puzzle could still be solved.

First moveNumber of movesSolvable ones
All351113 (about 30%)
Put in a color showing on top of 2 or more tubes15587 (56%)
Put in a color that is on top of only 1 tube19626 (13%)

Of the first moves, only about 30% can be solved. If you choose wrong, the puzzle can’t be solved after the very first move (in the app, if you press “Hint,” it tells you “Undo ×1 to get back on track”).

And moves that put in a color showing on top of 2 or more tubes could be solved a little more than half the time (56%). Moves that put in a color on top of only 1 tube could be solved just 13% of the time.

Example: Only the Three Moves That Put In Red Can Be Solved

The next puzzle is a ★5 puzzle made the same way the app does.

12345678910

Look at the top colors: red shows on tubes 1, 5, and 7, three tubes, and lime shows on tubes 2 and 9, two tubes. When I tried all 9 first moves, only the three moves that put red into tube 10 could be solved.

  • Red (tubes 1, 5, 7): Solvable.
  • Lime (tubes 2, 9): Not solvable.
  • Others (tubes 3, 4, 6, 8): Not solvable.

If you put in red, you can gather the other reds on top of the other tubes into tube 10 too, and the gaps in the tubes keep growing. Lime also shows on top of two tubes, but the moves that put in lime couldn’t be solved. A “color showing on top of 2 or more tubes” is a good candidate, but it isn’t guaranteed to be solvable.

12345678910
Move 1: 1→10
12345678910
Move 2: 5→10
12345678910
Two reds gathered

The app’s solver started by gathering the reds from tubes 1 and 5 into tube 10, and solved it in 29 moves.

How to Play with One Spare Tube

  1. At first, put a color showing on top of many tubes into the empty tube. If there are two or more candidate colors, check a few moves ahead, for each one, that you still have moves after putting it in.
  2. Don’t fill the gaps right away. After you’ve used the empty tube, a gap becomes a “stand-in for an empty tube.” What color you put in a gap matters as much as it does for an empty tube.
  3. Get the empty tube back early. When a chance comes to put a stored color back onto the same color, think about making an empty tube again (see How to Use Empty Tubes).
  4. When you’re stuck, go back without hesitating. In ★5, a one-move difference can make the puzzle unsolvable. “Undo” is free as many times as you like.

Practice for ★5

  • In ★3 and ★4, play as if you were going to solve it using only one empty tube, and you’ll get closer to the feel of ★5.
  • Use the example in Puzzles with Traps to check the idea of “gathering the colors showing on top.”

Other ideas are in Water Sort Tips, and the number of colors at each difficulty is in How to Choose a Difficulty.