The rules of Spider Solitaire are the same on every level. The only difference is the number of suits used. Even so, Hard (4 suits) becomes so difficult that it feels like a completely different game from Easy (1 suit). Here we look at the reason in numbers.
With 4 suits, a same-suit partner is 1 in 4
Take a card, say the 9 of spades. The “one rank lower” cards (8s) that can go on it number 8 among the 104 cards on every level. How many of those are the same suit (spades)?
| Level | 8s of the same suit | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Easy | 8 of 8 | 100% |
| Normal | 4 of 8 | 50% |
| Hard | 2 of 8 | 25% |
The only cards you can move together are a run in the same suit (Why connect in the same suit). On Hard, only 1 in 4 of the cards you can stack on is in the same suit.
The longer the run, the less the suits match
If you stack without minding suits, other suits get mixed into the middle of a run. If the suit of each card you stack were decided at random, the odds that a run of 5 cards is all one suit would be as follows.
| Level | Calculation | Odds |
|---|---|---|
| Easy | 1 × 1 × 1 × 1 | 100% |
| Normal | 1/2, four times | about 6% |
| Hard | 1/4, four times | about 0.4% |
From the first card you stack to the second, the third and so on, each time the question is “is it the same suit?” On Normal, only 1 time in 16, and on Hard only 1 time in 256, does a run of 5 cards line up in one suit by itself. On Hard, it is essential to stack by choosing so that the suit matches.
In column 1, the ranks are consecutive but the suits are all different. The only card you can move is the single 5 of spades at the top. Column 2 is all hearts, so you can move all 5 cards together.
A difference even in the first 10 cards
We dealt 104 cards 1 million times and counted the odds that the 10 face-up cards at the start include a pair you can stack in the same suit (How many ways can Spider be dealt?).
| Level | A same-suit stack is possible |
|---|---|
| Easy | 99.4% |
| Normal | 96.2% |
| Hard | 82.6% |
On Hard, about 1 time in 6 there is no pair you can stack in the same suit from the very start. From the beginning, you have to choose between stacking on a different suit or dealing the stock.
Empty columns matter more
To move a run broken up by mixed suits, you need an empty column. With one empty column you can carry 2 pieces, and with two, 4 pieces (How to use an empty column).
The more suits there are, the more finely runs are broken up, so you need more empty columns to carry them. This is why whether you can make one empty column on Hard often decides the game.
Summary
- On Hard, only 1 in 4 of the cards you can stack on is the same suit.
- A long run almost never lines up in one suit unless you choose how to stack.
- Runs are broken up finely, so empty columns matter even more.
Tips for solving Hard are in How to solve Hard (4 suits), and how many deals can be solved on each level is in Spider win rates.
