“Mahjong Solitaire” means a puzzle you play alone with mahjong tiles. Like card solitaire, you can quietly play it by yourself. It does not use mahjong hands or scoring, so you can play it without knowing mahjong.

Mahjong Solitaire comes in two main types.

  • Remove tiles by linking them with a line: Shisen-Sho (Nikaku-tori)
  • Remove stacked tiles: The type known through “Shanghai”

In both, you win by removing tiles with the same picture two at a time until none are left. What differs is the rule for which two tiles you can remove.

Shisen-Sho: Laid Out Flat, Linked by a Line

In Shisen-Sho, the tiles are laid out flat in a single layer. You can remove two tiles with the same picture if a line with at most two turns can connect them while going around the other tiles. The line can also pass outside the board.

五索二萬三萬五索東南西北

A special feature is that tiles far apart can be removed as long as a line can be drawn between them. What you check is whether the path between the two tiles is open. See the diagrams in Shisen-Sho Rules: Remove Pairs with Up to Two Turns.

Shanghai Type: Stacked Up, Removed from the Edges

In Shanghai-style games, the tiles are stacked in several layers and arranged in the shape of a mountain. You can remove only “free tiles,” which meet both of these conditions.

  • No other tile sits on top of it.
  • At least one side, left or right, is open.

You can remove two free tiles with the same picture. You break the mountain down from the top, and you win when it is gone. What you check is whether the tile is blocked from above and from the sides.

Note that “Shanghai” is known as the name (product name) of a game released by a particular company. Many games with similar rules have been made under other names.

How the Two Differ

  • Layout: Shisen-Sho is flat (one layer). The Shanghai type is stacked (many layers).
  • Which two tiles you can remove: In Shisen-Sho, two tiles that a line can connect. In the Shanghai type, two tiles that are open on top and on one side.
  • What you think about: In Shisen-Sho, how to route the path. In the Shanghai type, which layer to break down first.
  • Visible tiles: In Shisen-Sho, all the tiles are visible from the start. In the Shanghai type, tiles in lower layers can be hidden under upper tiles.

In Shisen-Sho, all the tiles are visible, so you can think ahead and plan the order of removal. The Shanghai type has the fun of breaking down the mountain while imagining what is hidden underneath.

Which Should You Start With?

Learning the rules takes only a moment in either game.

  • If you like to think ahead carefully, or want a clean picture-matching game, we recommend Shisen-Sho.
  • If you like the look of a three-dimensional mountain coming down, the Shanghai type might suit you.

The Shisen-Sho app (Android) is Shisen-Sho on a 6 by 8 board with 48 tiles. Every deal is arranged so that you can always remove all the tiles, so even first-timers can play to the end. To get started, see How to Play Shisen-Sho.