Two people can play Bulls and Cows (called Hit & Blow in Japan) head-to-head with just paper and a pencil. The app “Bulls and Cows” is made for playing alone, but here is a way to play with two players guessing each other’s answers.

What you need

  • Paper and a pencil (one set per person)
  • Another sheet of paper to hide the answer (or just cover it with your hand)

How to play

  1. Decide the number of digits: 3 digits to start, and 4 digits once you are used to it.
  2. Write your answer: Each player writes a row of all-different digits on paper and turns it face down so the other player cannot see.
  3. Decide who goes first: Use rock-paper-scissors or the like.
  4. Take turns guessing: The first player says a guess for the other player’s answer. The other player compares it with their own answer and gives back the number of hits and blows. Next, the second player guesses and the first player gives back the clue.
  5. Solve it to win: When the hits equal the number of digits, it is solved.

Settling ties

The first player gets one more guess, so they have a small edge. To make it fair, you can use a rule like this.

  • If the first player solves it, the second player gets one more chance to guess. If the second player also solves it on that turn, it is a tie.

How to fill in a record sheet

Write your own guesses and the clues the other player gives back, one row at a time.

No.  Guess  Hits  Blows
1    012    0     1
2    345    0     2
3    134    0     2
4    403    3     0   Solved

If you write the digits 0 to 9 at the bottom and mark digits you know are not in the answer with ✗ and digits you know are in it with ○, it is easier to reason (How to Use the Memo).

To avoid mistakes in the clues

The biggest trouble in head-to-head play is the player giving the clues making a counting mistake. A wrong clue causes contradictions, and you can never reach the answer.

  • Point at each digit of the guess with a finger and check “right place,” “in it but in the wrong place” or “not in it” before you give the clue.
  • At the end, check the answer and look back together at whether the clues along the way were right.

Setting handicaps

  • Change the number of digits: The stronger player guesses a 4-digit answer, and the beginner guesses a 3-digit one.
  • Compete on the number of guesses: Instead of taking turns, each player solves at their own pace, and whoever solves it in fewer guesses wins.
  • One hint: The beginner can ask just once, “Is this digit in it?”

If you want to practice alone

To win head-to-head, the skill of solving in few guesses matters. To practice alone, try for the target number (6 for 3 digits, 7 for 4 digits) on the playable board on this site or in the app “Bulls and Cows.” Tips are collected in Tips for Bulls and Cows.