Bulls and Cows (called Hit & Blow in Japan) is a game you can play if you can read numbers and count. You do not need to do any arithmetic. Here is how to teach it when you play with a child.
1. Say hits and blows in other words
At first, saying hits and blows like this gets the idea across more easily.
- Hit: “The number and the place are both exactly right.”
- Blow: “The number is in there, but the place is wrong.”
Count with an example while the answer is still showing.
“The 4 in 472 is in the same place as the 4 in the answer, so that is a hit. The 7 and the 2 are in the answer, but in different places, so they are blows. 1 hit, 2 blows.” When you count, pointing at them one at a time with your finger helps prevent mistakes.
2. Start with 3 digits
We recommend starting with 3 digits. There are 720 candidate answers, and if you keep picking rows that fit the clues, you can get it in about 5 guesses on average.
- If the child plays the side that thinks up the answer, it is practice in counting hits and blows. Let the adult guess, and have the child give back the clues.
- When the child becomes the guesser, write each guess and clue on paper, one row at a time.
3. Ideas for playing on paper
- Write 0 to 9 along the bottom of the paper, and put a ✗ on a number once you know it is not in the answer.
- The person giving the clues writes the answer and the guess next to each other and compares them one at a time before speaking.
- At first, you can also enjoy it by skipping 0 and using only 1 to 9, or by starting with 2 digits.
How to play on paper is also covered in more detail in Bulls and Cows for Two Players.
4. Things to say that bring out thinking
Rather than giving the answer, we recommend saying things that give them a reason to think.
- “What do you get when you add the hits and blows?” (They notice the number of digits that are in the answer.)
- “We know this number is not in it now, right?” (It leads to the ✗ memo.)
- “Does this row fit the clues from before?” (They think about guesses that do not contradict the clues.)
Rather than praising the number of guesses, ask “Why did you think so?” and praise them when they can put their line of thought into words. That is how the fun of reasoning comes across.
5. Playing alone in a browser or the app
To play alone, you can play 3 digits on the playable board on this site without installing anything. The computer picks the answer and gives the clues without making mistakes.
The app “Bulls and Cows” shows ads. When your child plays, it is reassuring if a parent first checks how to play and the settings. Watching a video ad, for example to get more Hints, happens only when the player chooses to.
The rules in full are collected in Rules of Bulls and Cows.
