In water sort (Sort Puzzle), the question that makes people hesitate is “which color should go in which tube?” There is no fixed order, but if you look at the colors at the bottom of the tubes, you get a sense of which tube will end up holding which color.
A Bottom Color Never Changes Unless You Empty the Tube
In a tube, you can move colors only from the top. The color at the very bottom moves only when you take everything out of that tube and it becomes empty.
When you clear a puzzle, each color has all 4 pieces together in one tube. That means:
- A tube you never empty ends up as the tube for its bottom color.
- If one color is at the bottom of two tubes, one of them has to be emptied at some point (because there can be only one tube for each color).
- A color that is at the bottom of no tube has to be gathered into an empty tube, or into a tube you emptied along the way.
These three hold true for every puzzle.
Checking with an Example
The next puzzle is the same size as ★1 in the app Sort Puzzle.
The bottom colors are lime in tube 1, yellow in tube 2, and sky blue in tubes 3 and 4. Green is at the bottom of no tube. From this, you can read the following.
- Tube 1 looks like it will be the lime tube, and tube 2 the yellow tube.
- Sky blue is at the bottom of tubes 3 and 4, so one of them has to be emptied at some point.
- Green gets gathered into the empty tube 5 or 6.
In the shortest solution found by trying every move (11 moves), it turned out exactly that way.
See the 11 moves
- On move 1, put the two greens into the empty tube 5. Tube 5 becomes the green tube.
- Gather yellow into tube 1 and lime into tube 3, then on move 7 gather the yellows into tube 2. On move 8, gather the limes into tube 1.
- Finally, move the three sky blues in tube 3 into tube 4. Tube 3 becomes empty, and tube 4 becomes the sky blue tube.
Tube 1 sorted as lime, tube 2 as yellow, and tube 4 as sky blue: every tube that was never emptied sorted by its bottom color. Tube 3, whose bottom overlapped with another, was emptied at the end, and green, which had no bottom, sorted in the empty tube 5.
For 30 ★1 puzzles made the same way the app does, I checked the shortest solutions, and in every puzzle, at least as many tubes were emptied as the number of overlapping bottoms.
How to Think About the Order of Gathering
- A tube whose bottom color doesn’t overlap with any other is where that color goes. When you find that color, wait for the top of that tube to clear and put it in.
- For a color whose bottom overlaps, decide first which tube to empty. The fewer colors are piled on top of a tube, the easier it is to empty.
- A color with no bottom is a candidate for the empty tube. Even so, for your first move it can be better to put in a color showing on top of several tubes (see How to Use Empty Tubes).
The app’s solver also counts how many tubes each color sits at the bottom of, as a measure of how far it is from being sorted (see Solving It by Computer).
Other ideas are in Water Sort Tips.
