In water sort (Sort Puzzle), you can move a color only onto “a tube whose top color is the same” or into “an empty tube.” Of those, an empty tube can take any color, and it’s the only place that can. Depending on how you use it, you either solve the puzzle cleanly or get stuck right away.

Your First Move Has to Go into an Empty Tube

A puzzle in the app Sort Puzzle starts with every tube that holds colors full, with 4. Nothing goes into a full tube, so the only place you can move to at first is an empty tube.

12345
The only place to move is tube 5

In this puzzle, you start by putting the top of one of tubes 1 to 4 into the empty tube 5. Which color you put in is the first important choice.

The Color You Put In Decides Where That Tube Goes

Once you put a color into an empty tube, it becomes a tube that “can take only that color.” You can’t use it for any other color until you’ve gathered all of that color or moved it back somewhere.

So the colors that suit an empty tube are colors showing on top of several tubes. In the puzzle above, yellow shows on top of tubes 3 and 4. If you gather the two yellows into tube 5, you get one gap in each of tubes 3 and 4.

12345
Move 1: 3→5
12345
Move 2: 4→5
12345
Two gaps opened up

In the puzzle with a trap too, gathering the blue showing on top of three tubes into an empty tube was the start of the solution.

Moves That Do Nothing

In Pour mode, pouring a one-color tube into an empty tube doesn’t change anything. Because a run of one color is poured all at once, the contents just move over to the next tube.

12345
Pouring the blue from tube 2 into tube 5 just swaps where the tubes are

The app’s solver doesn’t even look at this move, because it leads to the same position. When you have two empty tubes, it makes no difference which one you use either, because only the order of the tubes changes.

Making an Empty Tube Again

Even after you use an empty tube, if you put the color you stored back onto the same color, it becomes empty again. Let’s follow the first puzzle with the shortest solution, found by trying every move.

12345
Move 1: 3→5
12345
Move 2: 4→5
12345
Move 3: 3→4
12345
Move 4: 2→3 (2)
12345
Move 5: 4→2 (2)
12345
Move 6: 5→4 (2)
12345
Tube 5 is empty again
  1. Gather the two yellows into the empty tube 5 (moves 1 and 2).
  2. In the tubes that now have gaps, gather the green and orange onto the same colors (moves 3 to 5).
  3. When yellow shows on top of tube 4, put the two yellows in tube 5 back into tube 4 (move 6).

On move 6, tube 5 is empty again, and tube 4 holds three yellows in a row. This puzzle is sorted from here in 6 more moves, 12 in all.

If you think of an empty tube not as “a place to leave things for good” but as a place to store something for a while and return it later, it’s easier to see when to use it.

Summary

  • Your first move has to go into an empty tube. Which color you put in matters.
  • If you put in a color showing on top of several tubes, the gaps multiply at once.
  • Pouring a one-color tube into an empty tube is pointless.
  • If you put the stored color back onto the same color, you can make an empty tube again.

How to think about ★5, which has just one spare tube, is in How to Solve ★5 (One Spare Tube), and other ideas are in Water Sort Tips.