When Bulls and Cows (called Hit & Blow in Japan) gives you “0 hits, 0 blows,” it feels like a miss. But it is actually a very big clue, because you learn that none of the symbols you guessed is in the answer.
What do you learn?
With 3 digits, if “012” got 0 hits and 0 blows, none of 0, 1 and 2 is in the answer. The answer is a row chosen from the remaining 7 symbols, 3 to 9. The candidates drop from 720 to 7 × 6 × 5 = 210.
If you use the memo, put ✗ on 0, 1 and 2 together. The board shows the point where the 2nd guess, “345,” also got 0 hits and 0 blows, so the 6 symbols 0 to 5 have ✗ (How to Use the Memo).
How likely is it?
We counted all the answers to calculate how likely 0 hits and 0 blows is on the 1st guess.
| Digits | Answers giving 0 hits, 0 blows | Chance |
|---|---|---|
| 3 digits | 210 | about 29.2% |
| 4 digits | 360 | about 7.1% |
| 5 digits | 120 | about 0.4% |
| 6 digits | 0 | 0% |
| 7 digits | 0 | 0% |
With 3 digits it comes up almost 1 time in 3, but it gets much rarer as the digits increase.
Why it does not happen with 6 or more digits
There are only 10 symbols. A 6-digit guess uses 6 symbols, and the answer uses 6 symbols too. That is 12 in all, but there are only 10 symbols, so at least 2 must be the same symbol. In other words, with 6 digits, at least 2 of the symbols you guessed are always in the answer, and the total of hits and blows is 2 or more. With 7 digits, the total is always 4 or more.
On ★4 (6 digits) and ★5 (7 digits), 0 hits and 0 blows never appears. Instead, when the total is at its smallest (2 for 6 digits, 4 for 7 digits), you know that all the symbols you did not use in the guess (4 for 6 digits, 3 for 7 digits) are in the answer.
What to guess after 0 hits 0 blows
By calculation, when the 1st guess got 0 hits and 0 blows, making the 2nd guess all new symbols cut the candidates the most (a guess like “345” for 3 digits or “4567” for 4 digits).
In the example above, the 2nd guess, “345,” got 0 hits and 0 blows. Now 3, 4 and 5 are not in the answer either. What is left is rows of 3 chosen from the 4 symbols 6, 7, 8 and 9, which is 4 × 3 × 2 = 24. The symbols used in the answer are narrowed down to 3 of 6, 7, 8 and 9 (the memo below the board).
Is it okay to “aim for” 0 hits 0 blows?
Deliberately looking for symbols that are not in the answer is one way to narrow down the symbols. But while 0 hits and 0 blows gives you information about as many symbols as you guessed, it gives you no clue about places. Once the symbols are narrowed down, switch to guesses that move the places and watch the number of hits.
Other tips are collected in Tips for Bulls and Cows.
