★3 to ★5 in the app “Bulls and Cows” are 5, 6 and 7 digits. There are only 10 symbols, so with many digits, only 5, 4 or 3 symbols are left out of the answer. The way of thinking changes a little from 3 and 4 digits.
| Difficulty | Digits | Candidates | Target number |
|---|---|---|---|
| ★3 | 5 digits | 30240 | 8 |
| ★4 | 6 digits | 151200 | 9 |
| ★5 | 7 digits | 604800 | 10 |
5 digits: do not make the 2nd guess “all new symbols”
With 4 digits, an easy method was to guess different symbols each time, 0123 first and 4567 second. But with 5 digits, if you guess 01234 first and 56789 second, the total of the 2nd guess can be worked out without guessing.
A 5-digit answer uses 5 symbols, so if 01234 has a total of 3, the total of 56789 is always 5 − 3 = 2. The only new thing you learn from the 2nd guess is the number of hits (the places).
So from 5 digits on, the basic approach for the 2nd guess is to use some of the 1st guess’s symbols in different places and mix in new symbols.
6 and 7 digits: some symbols must be in the answer
A 6-digit guess uses 6 symbols, and the answer uses 6 symbols too. You are placing 12 symbols among 10, so at least 2 must overlap. With 7 digits, at least 4.
- With 6 digits, if the total is 2, the 4 symbols you did not use in the guess are all in the answer.
- With 7 digits, if the total is 4, the 3 symbols you did not use in the guess are all in the answer.
The more digits there are, the faster it can be to look for “symbols that are not in the answer.” With 7 digits, only 3 symbols are not in the answer.
An example 5-digit game
| Guess | Clue | Candidates left |
|---|---|---|
| 01234 | 0 hits, 3 blows | 6400 |
| 13475 | 0 hits, 3 blows | 1288 |
| 34780 | 1 hit, 3 blows | 71 |
| 74306 | 1 hit, 4 blows | 4 |
| 37046 | 5 hits | Solved |
The 2nd guess, “13475,” uses 1, 3 and 4 from the 1st guess in different places and adds the new symbols 7 and 5. From the 3rd guess on, we picked rows that split what is left well from among the rows that fit the clues. It was solved in 5 guesses (the target is 8).
An example 7-digit game
The candidates shrank from 604800 to 114030, 12128, 229, 29, 4 and 1, and it was solved in 7 guesses (the target is 10).
About how many guesses does it take?
We repeated “pick one row from those that fit the clues and guess it,” using random answers.
| Digits | Games tried | Average | Within target |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 digits | 10000 | about 6.0 | about 99.7% |
| 6 digits | 2000 | about 6.6 | 100% |
| 7 digits | 600 | about 7.5 | about 99.7% |
Even with more digits, the average grows by only about 1 guess at a time. If you keep picking rows that fit the clues, you reach the target number in most games.
Tips for solving in your head
- Use the memo: With many symbols, if you do not mark ✗ and ○, you lose track of which symbols you have tested (How to Use the Memo).
- Write a table of places: Writing down the symbols that cannot go in each place helps when you think about the order.
- Use the hint: The app’s “Hint” tells you slots the clues prove, or symbols that are not in the answer.
The ways of thinking for 3 and 4 digits are explained in Solving 3 Digits and Solving 4 Digits.
